My 3 Step Process for Customers Who Think Your Prices Are Too High

“How do I price my products? What do I charge?”

It’s one of our most common questions, and why we created our free pricing course + calculator last week.

farming, small farm, customers, farm to consumer, csa, raw milk, grassfed, joel salatin, farm marketing, business, flower farm, florist, prices

However, it’s brought up lots of comments about customers who challenge our prices. It’s a given that the prices for our handcrafted, homegrown, sustainable, or artisan goods are going to be higher priced than one might find for similar products in the store or on Amazon.

When produced on such a small scale, they require far more resources, and we must reflect that in the price. Also, they are typically far healthier, in the case of food and vegetables, and fresher and more unique in the case of flowers.

It’s a “given” for you and I, right? But that is not necessarily a given for our customers who seek us out for the first time.

Opened Up To Scrutiny

When we decide to start our farm and help people by selling them our handiwork direct to consumer, a side challenge comes up that we didn’t expect – we open ourselves up to scrutiny on everything!

When I’m thumbing through an online catalog, or walking through a department store, and am aghast at the price on a pair of cute shoes (that weren’t meant to be), there’s no one there to take my criticism, and I wander on.

But when you’re standing there on your farm, in your booth, at your drop site there’s nothing in between you and your customer’s initial sticker shock – you have to stand there and take it!

That can make us defensive and super-tempted to be snarky right back – “well if you want Walmart prices then feel free to head there,” is a commonly suggested response from well-intentioned fellow farmers. Or, “fire that customer!”

Sadly, this will just drive you out of business.

A Way You Can Flourish

I believe in, I practice, and I teach “farm marketing from the heart.” As a matter of fact, I wrote the book on it! (ha!!)

The reason I titled my book and my signature course that way is that when we communicate from a heart of compassion, and we remember to step into our customer’s shoes, we realize that we just had sticker shock yesterday.

And last week. And last month.

You and I have sticker shock all the time. So we have no business getting nasty with our customers.

You and I were once new to farm fresh food, too. I remember that first gallon of raw milk I bought for $12 almost 12 years ago. I had no clue why it was so much money. The farmer did a fantastic job of being compassionate and educating me. Didn’t make me feel dumb one bit! Looking back, they handled it with such grace.

farming, small farm, csa, sustainable, women who farm, price, get more customers, grassfed, raw milk, pastured, rotational grazing, joel salatin, hydroponics, flower farmer

When we forget we were once there, that we have questioned others’ prices, too, and we choose to take our defensiveness out on our customers, we are chasing our customers away and jumping on the fast track to bankruptcy. Please don’t let this be you.

There is a better way, the way I call “marketing from the heart.”

It has the opposite effect of ‘snarky-marketing’ – it builds up a solid, supportive, customer base much quicker.

And did you know, when you practice my 3 step plan with compassion, these complainers often become your biggest champions, referring you hordes of customers?

In the video below we talk about just that – why you and I must remember that we, too, have sticker shock on a regular basis. Therefore, if we have a plan in place to deal with it in our businesses, we’ll be successful and feel so good about having treated a fellow human being with the respect they warranted.

The 3 Step Process to Handle the Criticism

I’ve developed a 3 step process that I use with everyone who questions, exclaims, or is aghast at my $24/gallon milk. Read through the plan, customize it for yourself and even practice it out loud. It’ll make you far more likely to respond with grace and compassion, and you’ll have a far better chance of gaining a rockstar customer!

farming, small farm, customers, farm to consumer, csa, raw milk, grassfed, joel salatin, farm marketing, business, flower farm, florist, prices

Especially now that many of you have taken our free pricing course and realized you need to increase your prices, you’ll want to prepare your response so you feel confident.

1) Affirm to them that yes, they are correct.
Please make sure to use an encouraging, compassionate voice tone, not sarcastic (as tempting as that is, that’s your defensiveness trying to rear its ugly head, and you can rise to a higher level with a compassionate response).

Here’s how it may sound: “yes, you sure can get milk at the store for $5 a gallon. I know our price must be a shock to you! It sure was to me when I first started buying farm fresh milk ten years ago.”

(See how you’re showing empathy, building rapport and trust? They will appreciate you not making them feel stupid for their automatic response).

2) Give a short explanation.
Short is key. Don’t go into all your costs – that opens you up for more scrutiny. Just pick your 2-3 favorite reasons your product is costlier than others.

Again, squelch the defensive voice tone and please be encouraging. Explain to them, “I know it can be a shock at first, and there are a few reasons our product is more expensive. I’m a small farm with 3 cows, and milk in the stores comes from feedlots with 1,000’s of cows, so therefore the cost of production of milk in the stores is a fraction of my costs. Here’s a blog post (or handout) where I go into several reasons why our customers will choose to buy our milk even though they are on a budget and they can find it cheaper in the store. I know it seems like a high price compared to similar products, and this article should give you some insight into our handcrafted product.”

3) Give them loving permission to make another choice.
It’s amazing how their guard comes down when you use your most compassionate, understanding and encouraging voice tone and say something like, “I totally understand not everyone can make a choice to buy our product. Sometimes you’ve got to prioritize something else in your life besides (our flowers, eggs, milk, etc.) and I 100% get that. We’ve all got different things going on in our families and must spend our dollars accordingly. Our milk does not work for everyone’s budget. If you decide it works for you, we’d love to have you.”

I use this three step process all the time!! I teach it to my employees, too. And it has the most wonderful effect. People love us!! We make them feel safe being themselves and having a reasonable response to something they’ve never experienced before, such as homegrown products that are twice (or more) the cost of a store.

Your Former Criticizers are now your Biggest Supporters!

And the neatest thing happens – even those who choose not to buy from us because they prioritize something else in their budgets leave our farm and send lots of referrals our way!! They’ll tell people things like, “If our budget allowed for raw milk we’d get it from this farm!”

But if you give them that sarcastic response (that is oh-so-tempting, trust me, I know) you’ll hurt their feelings, and they’ll respond in a nasty way to cover up the hurt, and not only will you never see them again, they’ll say not-so-nice things about you, too. All because of how you made them feel.

You and I have the opportunity to make everyone feel great about themselves when they approach us. When we practice this 3 step process, we will have an army of people out there spreading the word about how wonderful our farm is, no matter the cost, all because we made them feel good about themselves and safe asking questions.

I hope you’ll join me in marketing from a place of compassion and empathy – you’ll see your farm transform and flourish before your eyes!



PS: be sure to grab our free pricing course, delivered by email. 

Did you like this episode?

If you got value out of this episode, I’d be really grateful if you left me a review over on iTunes, too. Those reviews help other people find my podcast and they’re also fun for me to go in and read.

Just click the link above to review, select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” and let me know what your favorite part of the podcast is. Thank you!

You might also like:

Hi, I'm Charlotte Smith!

I’ve made it my career to give farmers the mindset and the marketing strategy they need to have a farm and life they love.

Click below to find out why:

Want to get more customers to your farm? Click below to sign up and get your FREE checklist.

Subscribe to the Profitable Mindset podcast to learn how you can build a profitable farm without the overwhelm.

Sign up for updates and get
your FREE checklist:

How to Get More Customers to Your Farm

*We do not sell or spam your email. You can unsubscribe anytime.